Series synopsis
I Killed My BFF is an American crime documentary television series that premiered on Lifetime on June 25, 2012. It stars Katarina Hughes, Erin Bartley, Patrick Fleury and Kathleen Meyer.
There are consequences when BFFs - short for best friends forever - turn into frenemies. Episodes showcase true stories of intense friendships - and, in some cases, more than that - taking a bad turn that results in the most tragic ending possible for at least one person involved in the relationship. The show serves as a reminder to viewers that not even the best of friends keep that status forever.
Premise
There are consequences when BFFs - short for best friends forever - turn into frenemies. Episodes showcase true stories of intense friendships - and, in some cases, more than that - taking a bad turn that results in the most tragic ending possible for at least one person involved in the relationship. The show serves as a reminder to viewers that not even the best of friends keep that status forever.
Cast and characters
Leading cast
- Katarina Hughes as Amanda Drucker
- Erin Bartley as Melissa McCrayer
- Patrick Fleury as Josh Drucker
- Kathleen Meyer as Lora Nikolova
- Alexander Neil Miller as Andrew Roberts
- Paula Rossman as Bar Patron
- Reginald L. Barnes as Steven
- Jenna Ciralli as Patient
Supporting cast
- Mark Green as Robert Fuller
- Martel Huggins as Jamien
- Mary Liz Lewis as Teacher
- Erica Lutz as Misti Mayo
- Regine Mont-Louis as Edwanna
- James Pravasilis as Detective
- Alyse Mandel as Linda
- Matt Bailey as Frat Brother
- James Dicarlo as Ed Sigler
- Steve Garfanti as Detective
- Jacqueline Donelli as Linda
- Steve M. Robertson as Butch Pratt (voice)
Guest cast
- Katarina Hughes as Amanda Drucker
- Erin Bartley as Melissa McCrayer
- Patrick Fleury as Josh Drucker
- Kathleen Meyer as Lora Nikolova
- Alexander Neil Miller as Andrew Roberts
- Paula Rossman as Bar Patron
- Reginald L. Barnes as Steven
- Jenna Ciralli as Patient
- Mark Green as Robert Fuller
- Martel Huggins as Jamien
- Mary Liz Lewis as Teacher
- Erica Lutz as Misti Mayo
Episodes
This series spans 4 seasons with 33 episodes.
| Season | Episodes | First aired | Last aired |
|---|---|---|---|
| Season 1 | 9 | June 25, 2012 | April 29, 2013 |
| Season 2 | 8 | August 11, 2013 | October 6, 2013 |
| Season 3 | 8 | October 22, 2014 | December 17, 2014 |
| Season 4 | 8 | October 22, 2014 | December 17, 2014 |
| Episode | Title | Air date |
|---|---|---|
| 1 |
Do Unto Others Josh Drucker is a preacher's son with a calling to the ministry. Andrew Robertson is a bouncer and construction worker with a taste for motorcycles. They never would have met, if Andrew hadn't fallen for Josh's younger sister. What starts out as an unlikely friendship becomes a deep bond, until a tragic event leads to suspicion and revenge. When the smoke clears, two people are dead ... and one is on the way to Death Row. |
June 25, 2012 |
| 2 |
West Texas BFF's Growing up in a small Texas town, Misti Mayo and Christine Smith share everything: clothes, music, even teen pregnancy. But a move to the big city introduces them to a new lifestyle and a new group of friends. They find themselves in a spiral of bad decisions and escalating violence. With their backs against the wall, each of the girls has to choose between herself... and her best friend. |
July 9, 2012 |
| 3 |
Frat Brother Homicide Butch Pratt and Ed Swiger meet as freshmen at an idyllic college campus in western Pennsylvania. They're fast friends, fraternity brothers, and ultimately college roommates. Both are on the way to postgraduate studies and glowing careers. But a botched prank against their own fraternity suddenly puts the law on their tails. And with their futures at stake, one of them decides that success is worth killing for. |
July 9, 2012 |
| Episode | Title | Air date |
|---|---|---|
| 1 |
Power of Attorney Gerry Scotti and Barry Feldman are living the good life in Los Angeles. Gerry is a high-powered defense attorney, Barry his brilliant paralegal. They become best friends, each complementing the other's strengths and weaknesses. But there's a dark side to their work, defending drug dealers and other accused criminals. And Barry has a problem, a gambling addiction that already landed him in jail. As the stakes get higher, one of them will do anything to avoid losing it all. |
August 11, 2013 |
| 2 |
The New Girl At a school for at-risk youth in Illinois, Sarah Kolb rules the hallways. She takes new student Adrianne Reynolds under her wing, showing her the ropes and introducing her to the popular crowd. As the two get closer and closer, people around them start to wonder if they're more than best friends. But in this school, only one of them can be the most popular. Jealousy leads to contempt, and rumors spread like wildfire... until a final showdown after class turns into a deadly confrontation. |
August 18, 2013 |
| 3 |
My Best Guy Friend Can guys and girls ever really be best friends? It's a question Alphonze Fitzhugh and Britani Coberly hear many times--and they always shrug it off. These Northern California teenagers are more like brother and sister, sharing a passion for sports and meeting up with their friends for bonfires in the local vineyards. But like a grape that isn't picked, this friendship withers on the vine. Hidden attraction turns into jealousy, which then sets off a chain reaction of anger and revenge. |
August 25, 2013 |
| Episode | Title | Air date |
|---|---|---|
| 1 |
Real Life Heathers Oct 22, 2014 Two West Virginia girls, best friends since third grade, turn on each other when a third girl transforms their solid duo into an unstable trio. When one of the girls goes missing, police focus in on her BFF and eventually prove that she's the killer. |
October 22, 2014 |
| 2 |
More Than Friends He was from the wrong side of the tracks, she was the apple of her parents' eye and had every advantage in life. Together they became unlikely best friends, until another girl, and a secret, come between them. Police in Arizona bear down on one of the BFFs until the truth comes out and the gruesome murder is solved. |
October 29, 2014 |
| 3 |
First Love Is the Deadliest Two girls in Pennsylvania grow up the best of friends, but things get rocky when they take the next step and become lovers. Add a third girl to the mix, and this relationship turns downright toxic. One of the girls ends up dead, and the other is sent to prison for the rest of her life. |
November 5, 2014 |
| Episode | Title | Air date |
|---|---|---|
| 1 |
Real Life Heathers Two West Virginia girls, best friends since third grade, turn on each other when a third girl transforms their solid duo into an unstable trio. When one of the girls goes missing, police focus in on her BFF and eventually prove that she's the killer. |
October 22, 2014 |
| 2 |
More Than Friends He was from the wrong side of the tracks, she was the apple of her parents' eye and had every advantage in life. Together they became unlikely best friends, until another girl, and a secret, come between them. Police in Arizona bear down on one of the BFFs until the truth comes out and the gruesome murder is solved. |
October 29, 2014 |
| 3 |
First Love Is the Deadliest Two girls in Pennsylvania grow up the best of friends, but things get rocky when they take the next step and become lovers. Add a third girl to the mix, and this relationship turns downright toxic. One of the girls ends up dead, and the other is sent to prison for the rest of her life. |
November 5, 2014 |
Production
Release
| Original network/platform | Lifetime |
|---|---|
| First aired | June 25, 2012 |
| Last aired | December 17, 2014 |
| Runtime | 42 minutes |
| Status | continue |
| Schedule | Wednesday at 22:00:00 |